TV ad about 'lazy' men banned after complaint

Suzanne Wilton and Chris Cobb, CanWest News Service

Published: Saturday, August 04, 2007

Calgarian Peter Regan, left, talking about a TV ad for retailer Rona

Peter Regan, a single father who complained about a Rona commercial, says he's tired of media images he believes negatively portray men and fathers.

Peter Regan, a single father who complained about a Rona commercial, says he's tired of media images he believes negatively portray men and fathers.
Photograph by : Ted Jacob, Calgary Herald

 

A single dad in Calgary has succeeded in a complaint against home renovation giant Rona about a TV ad for the retailer he said portrayed men as "knuckle-dragging neanderthals."

After reviewing Peter Regan's complaint, a panel of industry experts agreed that the commercial was disparaging to men. Advertising Standards Canada has asked Rona to permanently withdraw the ad from Canadian TV.

In a letter to Regan this week, the watchdog said the ad

appeared to . . . be unwarranted, generalized, disparaging comment to the effect that all husbands are lazy."

Regan, 47, complained to the national advertising watchdog after being offended by a commercial that aired during a home renovation program he watched on HGTV this past May.

The commercial features a female customer going into a Rona store with an imaginary complaint called "homestressidous." A sympathetic female clerk suggests the customer's husband never helps out around the house. The customer confirms this and the clerk responds: "That's OK. They (husbands) are all like that."

Initially, Regan said he thought he misheard what was said. But seeing the commercial again later confirmed his first reaction.

"It was definitely portraying men, especially in the family unit, as lazy," said Regan.

Regan said Rona dismissed his complaint when he called and wrote about the commercial, saying the ad was meant to be funny.

A customer service representative who responded to him in writing said the commercial was one of four aimed at attracting female do-it-yourself customers.

"We wish to thank you for taking the time to shared (sic) your thoughts," said the letter to Regan, "for customers like you make it a little easier to pursue our goals. Thank you and have a nice day."

On Friday, a Rona spokeswoman told the Herald in an interview that the company was sorry.

"Rona's intention was never to offend anyone," said Eva Boucher-Hartling.

The commercial is no longer on the air, but only because it completed its six-week scheduled run in the spring, said Boucher-Hartling.

The company has not received the ruling on Regan's complaint -- the only one about the commercial, she pointed out. She was uncertain whether the ad is scheduled for another run.

Under Advertising Standards Canada regulations, Rona must either change or pull the commercial. The ruling, however, is not binding.

Regan said he was prompted to complain because he's tired of media images he believes negatively portray men and fathers. The stereotypes, he argued, rob boys and families of a positive role model.

"The average Canadian father is a decent human being," said Regan, who is alone raising his nearly 10-year-old son.

"We're tolerating these images (of men) as knuckle-dragging neanderthals. The media portrays fathers and grown men as habitual, lazy drunkards nowadays."

Last year, the advertising group received 1,040 complaints from consumers about 723 advertisements. Forty of those ads were judged to have contravened Canadian standards.

Retail or store advertising garnered the most complaints, followed by automobile commercials.

The watchdog would not comment on its ruling because Regan's complaint has not been made public by the watchdog.

swilton@theherald.canwest.com