Comedian Rosato found guilty

Canadian Press

KINGSTON, Ont. — Troubled comedian Tony Rosato has been found guilty of criminally harassing his wife.

Superior Court Justice Gordon Thomson then set aside the conviction and ordered the Toronto actor committed to a mental institution for a maximum of three years.

If Mr. Rosato is judged to be cured before that time, he will be released; if he is not, he will then face civil committal proceedings.

Normally, defendants found not criminally responsible by reason of mental disorder are committed to a mental hospital but may never get out from under court supervision.

Wednesday's decision sets a time line for how long they may be supervised by the courts.

Judge Thomson agreed to Crown laywer Priscilla Christie's request that the court grant a conditional discharge with a probation order requiring Mr. Rosato to get psychiatric treatment.

“This balances the interests of the accused with the interests of the victim and the public,” Ms. Christie told the court.

The judge noted that he found Mr. Rosato's rambling and often incoherent testimony on Tuesday “a very bizarre hour of evidence.”

Mr. Rosato, who suffers from Capgras syndrome, described how he concluded his wife was not the woman he married — speculating she had been replaced by twins or triplets — and that his infant daughter had also been replaced.

Mr. Rosato said he believes Leah Rosato's face was digitally removed from their wedding photos and another woman's put in and doubts it was even her who testified against him at the preliminary hearing.

He also said that during a court-ordered supervised visitation with his baby daughter, another couple's child was handed to him by a Children's Aid worker.

In his verdict, the judge said that Mr. Rosato's evidence did not raise any reasonable doubt in his mind that Mr. Rosato harassed his wife.

Judge Thomson stated that he was satisfied that Mr. Rosato did “frighten, scare, annoy, bedevil... badger..., continuously or chronically, until he wore his young wife down with fear and exhaustion.”

Mr. Rosato had pleaded not guilty.

The judge cited Leah Rosato's testimony that her husband had been abusive, that he had said her family was connected to pedophilia and incest, that he had called his wife “crack-whore” when she breastfed their baby and had said she was impure and needed to be purified, and that he shook the baby, yelled in her ears and was afraid of beings called “astral attackers.”

The judge noted in his verdict that Tony Rosato had become so controlling he forced his wife to cut off all contact with her family, and forced her to denounce them in a letter.

Mr. Rosato protested the verdict, claiming he had not been allowed to defend himself.

“I said ‘Excuse me, this is not my daughter,”' he recalled.

Mr. Rosato, born in Naples, Italy, joined SCTV in its final season in 1980, his best-known character a tippling TV chef named Marcello Sebastiano. He appeared on Saturday Night Live for one season in 1981, then in 1985 began a four-year stint on the popular Canadian police drama Night Heat.

Source

 

Our commentary in the Globe and Mail

September 5, 2007

  1. Ottawa Mens Centre.com, from Ottawa, Canada wrote: Kingston is famous for its feminist judges, and you can feel the hatred towards men literally oozing out of the courtroom walls. Today its koodos & 3 cheers for Justice Gordon Thomson, who did not have any other practical option. A not guilty verdict would have been an even graver injustice. It’s also a very sad day for Canadian justice when the crown are forced to obtain such a conviction just for the purposes of putting Rosato in a mental institution that will allow Rosato out just as soon as professionals utter an opinion that he is ready for the outside world. The mentally ill left untreated leave a trail of destruction and endless litigation. Rosato just happened to be male. If he was female, he probably would have not had any problem in getting Kingston Lawyer Lesley Kendal to help him out by personally fabricating evidence. Back in 2001, a judge in Sudbury issued an order for an expedited trial of custody after he was presented evidence of a mother admitting that she heard voices telling her to get out of an aircraft in flight and numerous unprovoked assaults. Lesley Kendal knew her client had admitted hearing voices, unprovoked extreme violence and if it came to a trial the mother would probably loose custody. In Kingston, that’s enough to get all three feminist judges into their bitchiest mode and do something nasty. But, Lesley Kendall of Cunningham Swan lucked out with Justice Denis Power and got him to issue a “permanent restraining order” claiming that the order for an expedited trial was “harassment” and personally gave her own fabricated evidence while representing her client, that too was AOK by Justice Denis Power of Ottawa. That’s what you call a very serious lack of empathy and contempt for the process of law, and, obstruction of justice by two officers of the court, a fembox lawyer with the gall to ask a judge to do something improper and a judge with an anger problem who improperly obliged her. http://www.OttawaMensCentre.com 613-797-3237

    Source

    1. You (Ottawa Mens Centre.com, from Ottawa, Canada) wrote: The terrible taboo of mental illness leaves a greater trail of destruction than that caused by the sufferers. The sufferers are generally not responsible for their actions. Unfortunately, all too often emergency physicians are called upon to make an "assessment" and simply get rid of "the patient" by declaring nothing wrong with them when a perfectly qualified mental health professional and the regular obs/gyn was on duty. Take Dr. Chris Loretto of Timmins Ontario, he decided he could make a negative diagnosis when in fact a mental health professional and the patients gyn/obs was available in the same building. After his negative assessment he heard first hand of serious aberrant behaviour, declined an appeal by the obs/gyn to reconsider his decision. Dr. Chris Loretto then called the mother of a 3 week old baby in to do a follow up visit, by himself to back up his own opinion which he knew or ought of known was a tragic but embarrassing error. He then to cover his trail of incompetence, testified in perjury trial to have the person who swore the mental health affidavit for the assessment convicted of perjury. That charge was thrown out at the first opportunity by the judge hearing the charge by indictment. That’s what you call a serious lack of empathy and compassion. He should stick to fixing muscles and bones. http://www.OttawaMensCentre.com 613-797-3237

    Source