PM launches blow at Senate

From Tuesday's Globe and Mail

Canberra — Canada's Prime Minister stood in the Parliament of Australia on the anniversary of the 9/11 terrorist attacks to talk about the close ties between the two nations and the "noble and necessary" responsibility they share for making the world a safer place.

But not before he took a hard swipe at the Liberal-dominated Canadian Senate, and lobbed a veiled threat that he could move to abolish the chamber if Senators did not agree to democratic reform.

"As one Canadian political scientist I know likes to say, when we look at Australia, we suffer from 'Senate envy,'" Stephen Harper told Australian senators and members of Parliament in the opening lines of his speech this morning.

"In Canada, senators remain appointed, not elected. They don't have to retire until age 75, and may warm their seats for as long as 45 years. By the nature of the system, they're not accountable to voters."

Australian senators, on the other hand, are elected — something Mr. Harper described as a minimum condition of 21st-century democracy.

"Australia's Senate shows how a reformed upper house can function in our parliamentary system," he said, "And Canadians understand that our Senate, as it stands today, must either change, or, like the old upper houses of our provinces, vanish."

It is unusual for world leaders to wade into domestic squabbles when they have been given an international podium. But Mr. Harper regularly criticizes his opposition while abroad, and the Senate is one of his favourite targets.

Liberal senators, who hold a majority in the chamber, decided not to vote on a bill that calls for eight-year limits on Senate terms until its constitutionality had been tested in the courts.

But that bill and another that would create a process for electing senators were killed by Mr. Harper's decision to prorogue Parliament.

The Prime Minister's address to the Australian politicians returns an honour that the Canadians bestowed last year upon Australian Prime Minister John Howard.

The two leaders have a strong friendship and share many of the same ideals.

Mr. Howard is in trouble domestically, however, with polls suggesting that Labour Leader Kevin Rudd would stroll to an easy victory in an election that could be called as early as this week.

For that reason, Mr. Harper also met Tuesday with Mr. Rudd, who wants to pull Australian troops out of Iraq but beef up the country's contingent in Afghanistan. That could help cement a bond between him and Mr. Harper, who wants Canadian troops to continue playing a large role in Afghanistan.

The duration of Canada's mission threatens to dominate debate in Ottawa this fall, with all three opposition parties demanding a clear signal that Canadian troops will pull out at the end of the mandate in February, 2009.

And Mr. Harper, who was substituted as guest speaker for the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks after Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe cancelled, took the opportunity of his address to stress the importance of maintaining a military presence in the region.

Although the troops of Canada and Australia have rarely fought on the same battlefield, he said, they have fought for the same ideals.

"We are fast friends of, but fiercely proud of our differences with, our other strategic cousin — the United States," he said.

But "Sept. 11, 2001, was truly a day that shook the world. Six years on, the horrific images from that morning still evoke anger, sorrow and — as intended — terror. The buildings may have been American, but the targets were every one of us."

Canadians have mourned the loss of Australian lives in subsequent terrorist attacks in places such as Bali, and have lost 70 of Canada's own soldiers in Afghanistan, he said.

"So both our countries have been bloodied by terror. And both of us are doing our part to confront and defeat it," Mr. Harper said.

"Because, as 9/11 showed, if we abandon our fellow human beings to lives of poverty, brutality and ignorance, in today's global village, their misery will eventually and inevitably become ours. And the world needs us to continue to serve as powerful models of prosperous and compassionate societies, independent yet open to the world."

Mr. Harper finished his address by describing the close ties between Canada and Australia and announcing an agreement to renew and expand the student working vacation program that exists between the two countries.

"This will give more young Canadians and Australians opportunities to visit each other's countries," he said, "and to widen the personal relations that increasingly bind our nations as family."

Source